Skip to content

Intervals

Temperament · Exhibit

Twelve fifths
miss seven octaves.

Stack pure fifths and the last pitch misses seven octaves by 23.46 cents. Seven steps show how tuners hid that leftover.

Step 3 of 7

The sixteenth-century bargain

Meantone hides the error in one fifth.

A Pythagorean major third comes from four pure fifths lowered by two octaves. Its ratio is 81:64. A pure major third is 5:4, and the 81:80 gap between them is the syntonic comma. Quarter-comma meantone narrows each common fifth by one quarter of that gap. After four fifths, the four small changes make the third pure. Eleven narrowed fifths leave the remaining interval at 737.64 cents, 35.68 cents above a pure fifth. These are reedy tones, because the howl lives in the upper partials an organ pipe supplies. The wolf exposes the cost of that bargain on fixed-pitch instruments.

Play the pure fifth and meantone wolf separately, then press Hear both fifths. Listen for the 701.96-cent pair to settle and the 737.64-cent wolf to rattle 16.3 times a second.

The pure upper tone is 392.44 Hz, and its second partial lands on the third partial of C4. The wolf reaches 400.61 Hz, so the same two partials miss by 16.3 Hz and buzz. Pietro Aron described a close method in 1523. The 678-cent wolf in the Story room comes from Pythagorean tuning.

Two commas

Cents measure each gap.

A comma is the leftover distance between two tunings that nearly agree. The Pythagorean one is 23.46 cents wide, about a quarter of a 100-cent step. The 21.51-cent syntonic comma lies between the 81:64 Pythagorean third and the pure 5:4 third.

Story · Discovery 5

You opened Temperament from Comma and wolf.

Return to Comma and wolf →

Temperament · Comma and compromise

Close the circle by shaving each fifth.

Drag the fifth narrower, watch the open circle close, then play the gap. Twelve pure fifths land 23.46 cents beyond seven octaves because the powers of 3 and 2 never meet. Equal steps distribute that miss by narrowing every fifth about two cents. Closing the picture reveals the compromise that lets a fixed keyboard use one tuning in every key.

Drag the fifth narrower, watch the circle close, then play the gap. Twelve pure fifths pass seven octaves by 23.46 cents, so equal steps narrow each fifth about two cents. The closed picture reveals the tuning compromise that lets one fixed keyboard play in every key.

Size the fifth701.96 ¢ fifth · twelve of them land 23.46 ¢ over